How much can you afford to pay per lead?

By the Ask Naly team · Updated

You can afford to pay up to the profit a lead brings you, and you want to pay a good bit less. To find that number, take the profit you make on an average job, then multiply it by the share of leads that turn into jobs. That's what one lead is worth to you. Industry averages won't tell you this, because they don't know your prices, your costs or how good you are on the phone.

Why "what's a good cost per lead?" is the wrong question

Owners ask this all the time, and the honest answer is: good for whom? A roofer who makes thousands on a job can pay far more for a lead than a dog groomer can. Two plumbers in the same town can have very different numbers if one closes most of the people who call and the other closes a few.

Published benchmarks mix all of that together. They might be close to your number or nowhere near it. Your own math takes ten minutes and it's the only number that actually tells you whether your ads make money.

The math, step by step

You need three things. Rough numbers are fine.

1. Average job value. What does a typical first job from a new customer bring in? Look at your last 20 or 30 jobs from new customers and take the average. If one huge job skews the average, look at what a typical job brings in instead.

2. Profit margin on that job. After parts, materials, labor and anything else the job costs you, what share is left? If you're not sure, be conservative.

3. Close rate. Out of every 10 people who call or fill out a form about real work, how many become paying customers? Count only real inquiries, not spam or wrong numbers.

Now put them together:

Profit per job = average job value × profit margin

What a lead is worth = profit per job × close rate

That last number is your break-even. Pay that much per lead and the ads pay for themselves, with nothing left over. It also only covers the job's own costs. Rent, insurance and the office still need paying, which is one more reason to aim well below it.

A made-up example

These numbers are invented to show how it works.

A small HVAC company's average first job is $500. After parts and labor, it keeps about 40%, so $200 profit per job. It books about 4 out of every 10 real leads.

  • Profit per job: $500 × 0.40 = $200
  • What a lead is worth: $200 × 0.40 = $80

So this business breaks even at $80 a lead. Paying $80 means working for nothing. A sensible target is well below that, so there's actual profit left. Where you set it depends on how much room you want.

What about repeat customers?

If customers come back year after year, a first job undersells them. A furnace tune-up customer who stays with you for years is worth more than one visit.

You can count some of that, but be careful. Only count repeat business you can actually see in your records. It's easy to talk yourself into a big lifetime value and then overpay for leads that never come back. If you want to be safe, set your target on the first job and treat repeat work as a bonus.

Use the number to judge your campaigns

Now look at each campaign's cost per lead for the last 30 days: spend divided by real leads, not just what Google calls conversions. Then compare:

  • Well under your target: this campaign earns. It may be worth giving it more budget.
  • Near your break-even: it's not losing money, but it's not making much either. Clean up wasted searches and check the landing page.
  • Over your break-even: it's losing money on every lead. Fix it or cut it back.

Our guide on telling if a Google Ads campaign is losing money covers what to check before you cut.

Keep the number fresh

Prices change, costs change, and your close rate changes if someone new answers the phone. Look at the three inputs again every few months. If your close rate drops, every lead is worth less, even if your ads didn't change at all. Sometimes the fix isn't in the ad account. It's in how fast you call people back.

Where Ask Naly fits

In Ask Naly's business settings you can enter your average profit per job. Naly uses your own number, not someone else's average: she won't tell you to put more money into a campaign when a paying job from it already costs as much as the job earns. You can change the number any time.

FAQ

What is a good cost per lead for a small business?

There isn't one number. A good cost per lead is one that leaves you profit after the job is done. Work it out from your average job value, your profit margin and how many leads you close.

Should I use revenue or profit to set my cost per lead?

Use profit. Revenue makes every lead look more valuable than it is, because it ignores what the job costs you to do.

My close rate is low. Should I lower what I pay per lead?

Yes, a lower close rate means each lead is worth less. But also look at why. Slow callbacks, missed calls and unclear pricing often hurt close rates more than the ads do.

How often should I recalculate?

Every few months, and any time your prices, costs or phone handling change.

More guides

Get startedAccess opens after approval.